Raising False Alarms – NYTimes.com

Excerpt from a great column by Bob Herbert in the New York TImes…

I’m so tired of people beating up Social Security.  It’s definitely one government program that works well and it is not in crisis.

Irresponsible Congressmen and the Corporate Media want us to think it’s in trouble so they can move toward unnecessary benefit cuts and privatization.

Let me repeat:  Social Security is sound.  It is not in trouble.  What little concerns exist could be alleviated by increasing the taxable income cap for Social Security to over $106K.  Today, once your salary hits $106K, you don’t pay any more Social Security Tax, remove the cap and there is no more question of insolvency for Social Security.

I keep hoping the truth will win out and the GOP hypocrites move on to something else…

Mugging the nation’s grandparents by depriving them of some of their modest, hard-earned Social Security retirement benefits is hardly an answer to the nation’s ills. And, believe me, those benefits are modest. The average benefit is just $14,000 a year, which is less than the minimum wage would pay. With employer-provided pensions going the way of the typewriter and pay telephones, the income from Social Security is becoming more precious by the day.

“If we didn’t have Social Security, we’d have to invent it right now,” said Roger Hickey, co-director of the Campaign for America’s Future. “It’s perfectly suited to the terrible times we’re going through. Hardly anyone has pensions anymore. People’s private savings have taken a huge hit, and home prices have been hit hard. So the private savings that so many seniors and soon-to-be seniors have counted on have just been wiped out.

“Social Security is still there, and it’s still paying out retirement benefits indexed to wages. It’s the one part of the retirement stool that is working.”

The deficit hawks and the right-wingers can scream all they want, but there is no Social Security crisis. There is a foreseeable problem with the program’s long-term financing, but it can be fixed with changes that do no harm to its elderly beneficiaries. One obvious step would be to raise the cap on payroll taxes so that wealthy earners shoulder a fairer share of the burden.

The alarmist rhetoric should cease. Americans have enough economic problems to worry about without being petrified that their Social Security benefits will be curtailed. A Gallup poll taken recently found that 90 percent of Americans ages 44 to 75 believed that the country was facing a retirement crisis. Nearly two-thirds were more fearful of depleting their assets than they were of dying. The fears about retirement are well placed — most Americans do not have enough to retire on. But there should be no reason to believe that Social Security is in jeopardy.

The folks who want to raise the retirement age and hack away at benefits for ordinary working Americans are inevitably those who have not the least worry about their own retirement. The haves so often get a perverse kick out of bullying the have-nots.

via Raising False Alarms – NYTimes.com.

Leave a comment

Filed under Health Care, Politics, The Economy

Leave a comment